Warning: This review contains spoilers for Uglies and Pretties. If you haven't read those yet, proceed at the risk of being spoilerized!Specials is the final book in the original
Uglies trilogy, set in a dystopian future where extreme surgery is compulsory at the age of sixteen. It's also the last instalment in the story of sixteen year old heroine Tally Youngblood. Having experienced life as an Ugly and a Pretty, Tally is now a Cutter - a super-strong, super-fast and somewhat scary junior member of Special Circumstances. It's her job to keep rebellious Uglies and Pretties in line, with the help of her icy new senses, her skintenna communication device and the equally Special members of her clique, the Cutters. It
should be easy. She's physically superior to the random Uglies, and mentally superior to the bubblehead Pretties. But at what cost?
Although the
Uglies trilogy follows the journey of a single protagonist, Scott Westerfeld gives us a different version of Tally Youngblood in each instalment. I have to confess that I liked the
Uglies Tally best - the tricky, flawed and slightly innocent everygirl just beginning to question the values that she'd taken for granted her whole life. In
Pretties, there was the sense that deep down that Ugly Tally still existed, and that reversing the bubblehead operation by whatever means might just bring her completely back. But in
Specials we get something different: a Tally Youngblood so utterly transformed that we begin to wonder whether the original exists anymore. Whilst this does mean that Tally is never quite as easy to relate to in
Specials as she was in book one, we are treated to a trickier version than ever before. So, there's plenty of nail-biting suspense and breathtaking action scenes to keep readers on the edge of their seats here.
In keeping with Tally's transformation, Westerfeld gives us the chance to see even more of her world in this instalment. She can go further, with fewer limits, and so can we. Most excitingly, we get to visit Diego - a whole new location, and one where the authorities have not reigned with such tight control as we're used to seeing in the previous two books. It's a vividly-drawn city where people have the freedom to look however they want, and take full advantage of it. It's also closer to our own society than Tally's own hometown, but the beauty of Diego is that having read the previous two books Westerfeld ensures that we look this relatively 'free' society with new eyes. There are those who have had surgery to look like traditional pretties, those who have opted for more extreme and outlandish enhancements, and those who have never changed a thing. There are those who want to blend in, and those who who want to stand out. And the population of Diego don't just express their differences in the way they look: they have different opinions, and different behaviours, and they're not afraid to clash. And having looked at Tally's world through the eyes of twenty-first century citizens in the first two books, it's now time for us to look at our world through Tally's eyes.
And this is where
Specials really gets clever. Having contemplated the evils of brainwashing, control and enforced uniformity in the previous novels, Westerfeld always made it clear that Tally's society had at some point felt this was wholly necessary. The Rusties (that's us) had nearly destroyed the planet with their wars and their irresponsible use of natural resources. The authorities' control had eradicated these dangers, but at the price of the citizens' humanity. Now we have to ask ourselves whether freedom is really better, when what it comes down to is the freedom to destroy the world - and each other. For me,
Specials is the most thought-provoking book in the trilogy. In fact, it provokes thoughts all over the place: on freedom, on self harm, on war, and even on real-life conflicts between cultures with different value systems. And there's no easy answers.
As well as the larger themes at work here, there's also some intriguing resolution to the relationships between Tally and the other characters she's come into contact with through the
Uglies trilogy. Let's start with the romance. By the end of
Pretties, many readers will be backing either Team David or Team Zane. Sure, Tally originally fell for David despite the fact he was Ugly, but in book two Zane turned out to be a worthy suitor for our heroine despite his Prettiness. As it turns out,
Specials throws us a real curveball on this one. Without giving too much away, get your hankies at the ready - there's a real tearjearker of a twist approaching. On the friendship front, Tally's uneasy friendship with Shay adds a welcome layer of crackling tension to proceedings, and we even finally understand just what the deal is with Dr Cable. Best of all, we're left with the sense that Tally has finally found a body she's comfortable in - and one that reflects who she really is, after all that she's been through.
Specials is an exhilirating and satisfying conclusion to the
Uglies trilogy. It's fast-paced, action-packed and seriously epic. Fan of YA dystopian fiction? Read
Uglies, read
Pretties, and then read this one.
Out: this edition, 4th March 2010, UKThank you to Simon and Schuster UK for providing a review copy of Specials with its gorgeous new cover.